Transparency And Food Colors

According to Nielsen’s 2016 Global Health and Ingredient Sentiment Survey, 75% of consumers around the world are concerned about the long-term health impact of artificial ingredients. Artificial colors (61%), artificial flavors (62%), and preservatives (62%) are the three most avoided ingredients. This data is very much in line with Sensient’s internal consumer research.

naturally-colorful-food-colorsInterestingly, however, the same study reported that 67% of consumers “want to know everything that is going into [their] food” and 70% of North Americans “feel more positively” towards companies that are transparent about how their products are grown and made. The latter finding is the most relevant because brands have a unique opportunity to build trust and loyalty with consumers.

Many leading food companies and brands have already begun to take steps to create more consumer loyalty.

Kroger, the leading supermarket operator in the United States, announced the launch of its own brand of cage-free eggs in addition to their commitment to be completely cage-free in the next decade.
Nestle established an aggressive five-year timeline to complete their own transition to cage-free eggs in U.S. food products.
The Grocery Manufacturers Association (GMA) and the Food Marketing Institute (FMI) jointly created the SmartLabel platform that has the potential, at least, to take transparency to a new level.
McDonald’s recently announced they are removing preservatives from several items, including the iconic Chicken McNuggets. The company had previously announced several initiatives, including cage-free egg sourcing, the removal of HFCS from buns, and the serving of only chicken free from antibiotics.

Product Launch Communication Strategy

The first phase in any transparency initiative is clearly the transformation of product formulations. But the next step, the communication of those changes, is a very strategic and critical step of a new product launch.

Kraft Heinz used a very unique approach with their Mac & Cheese launch recently. They made the switch to natural color but intentionally chose not to communicate anything for the first few months, only to later unveil the “It’s Changed. But it Hasn’t” campaign. Kraft Heinz’s priority was reassuring loyal consumers that neither the taste nor appearance of their beloved Mac & Cheese had been compromised. In August, Kraft Heinz management indicated sales volume was very strong post-renovation. Their communication plan appears to have been a successful strategy for the product relaunch.

Ferrara candy took a very different approach with their successful introduction of organic Black Forest gummi bears. In their “Real Gummies of the Black Forest” TV spots, the company uses humor to draw a comparison between their organic offerings and competitive products that are not as transparent.

In my view, companies who are increasing transparency will only increase their trust with consumers, but only by combining product formula changes with the right level of consumer engagement and dialogue.

Transparency of Natural Food Color

Consumers are increasingly defining “healthful” by what ingredients a product doesn’t contain. Despite a large amount of data pointing to the safety of certified food colors, consumers continue to avoid artificial ingredients. Furthermore, we expect more scrutiny in the coming years about the source and origin of food color. Natural color derived from plant sources that can be labeled as vegetable juices tends to be more favorable.

Additionally, we expect to see continued growth in certified organic packaged food products. While organic has been consistently growing, mainstream food retailers like Walmart and Kroger are closing the historic price gap, which is increasing the growth rate.

The consumer expectation of a safe food supply chain should certainly not be ignored. In fact, data indicates that manufacturers carry much more responsibility than retailers or food service operators.


At Sensient, we are working to help customers address consumer demand for transparency. Our Certasure program includes the industry’s most comprehensive food safety testing protocol. In addition to brand protection, the program also provides for full supply chain visibility. On the innovation front, we continue to develop new technologies and products that help our customers meet the need for transparency.

Related Posts

Mothers Know Best: How Moms are Influencing the Food and Beverage Industry

Rubio’s Fast-Casual Fresh Mex Restaurant Removes Caramel Coloring

How Big Food is Taking on a World of Picky Eaters

Kraft Heinz Doubles Oscar Mayer’s Marketing Budget to Promote Natural Ingredients

The Magically Colorful Unicorn Trend

Caribou Coffee Cutting Artificial and Caramel Coloring from Beverages

A Colorful Twist on a Sweet & Salty Snack

Food Color Effect on Older Consumers

Dunkin’ Donuts and Baskin-Robbins Removing Artificial Colors by End of 2018

Food Color is as Important as Taste

California Introduces “Warning Label” Bill for Foods Containing Artificial Dyes

Myth or Fact? Artificially-Colored Foods Are Bad for You

Further Concerns Over the Safety of Titanium Dioxide

Panera is 100% Additive-Free

Formulators Taking Solution-Approach to Natural

Consumers Emphasizing Ingredients on Food Labels

#TBT A Look Back at the Co-Creation of the Food Coloring Business

8 Foods You Would Never Guess Were Artificially Colored

Color of Food Guides our Brains

Naturally Coloring the Beverage Industry

Are Autumn Leaves the Next Source of Natural Color?

Food Colors Market to Reach $3.75 Billion by 2022

Spirulina Algae: Next Natural Food Trend

Why Blue Foods Are Perceived Less Natural

Big Brands Clean Up Portfolios for Consumers

Natural Colors Linked to Positive Health Effects

Many Food Companies are Cooking Up New Natural Recipes

SweeTARTS Launches Five New Custom Colored Gummies Shaped as School Mascots

European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) Continues Research on the Safety of Titanium Dioxide

A Deep Look into Spirulina: an Emerging and Popular Natural Color Source

Does Mac&Cheese Lead the ‘Free-From’ Trend?

Why Wegmans Removed Artificial Colors in their Icings

Food Companies Are Not Phasing Out Artificial Colors Fast Enough for Some

Heinz Removing Artificial Colors from Pickles

Kraft Launching Jell-O Line Without Artificial Colors

McDonald’s Removing Artificial Colors from Iconic Chicken Nuggets

Natural Colors ‘Upsurge’ in 2016 Market Share

Consumers Are Influenced by the Color of their Food